Blanche Crandall 
1200 I Street #303
Anchorage, AK. 99501
August 19, 2011
Rev. Edward Dougherty,MM
Office of the General Council
PO Box 303
Maryknoll, NY 10545-0303
Dear Fr. Dougherty and General Council:
Having  received a copy of your letter to Fr. Roy Bourgeois, I must be  straightforward in responding and write according to my conscience.
I  found the letter dated 27 July,2011 that you wrote to Fr. Bourgeois to  be non-pastoral and void of compassion. It included an account of past  events of the last few years concerning him, you, and the Vatican. The  rules and regulations referred to were written by dogmatic and  legalistic clerics not consistent with the compassionate and merciful  words of Jesus found in the gospels. Your words betray your allegiance  to an unjust system that is self-perpetuating and self-serving (Ps  118:8-9)
As a thinking Catholic woman, I find the words of Pope  John Paul II regarding women's ordination offensive. They betray the  mind and (heartless) heart of a  misogynist. You are aware of the Pontifical Biblical Commission of  1976, of the 200 some Biblical scholars and theologians who concluded  that nothing in the Bible forbids women's ordinations. John Paul II  chose to vehemently oppose the hard work of that commission and  squelched its study. Clearly, he was not at all thinking of the  unfolding of truth and thus being liberated by its light. Instead, he  was more interested in protecting an institution bent on  self-preservation than on justice.
Thomas Aquinas stated that no  one has the right to obey an unjust law or to follow false teaching. Our  first obligation is to our conscience. In this light, I support Fr.  Bourgeois' choice to follow his conscience.
John Henry Newman  wrote: "[in a] collision with the word of a pope.... [conscience] is to  be followed in spite of that word." He referred to the conscience as the  "Vicar of Christ" for each of us. It is noted that he toasted  conscience first  and the pope second.
Finally the words of then Joseph Ratzinger  in 1967: "Over the pope... there stands... conscience which must be  obeyed before all else, even if necessary against the ecclesiastical  authority."
I haven't heard that the Pope recanted those words.  So there is a contradiction with that statement and what the Pope is  presently telling you to do to Fr. Bourgeois because he is following his  conscience. I might suggest, before you continue with your Canonical  Warning, that you check with the Pope for clarification. The answer  should be told to all Catholics.
Last Sunday's (8-7-11) Gospel  from Matthew tells of Peter walking on the water toward Jesus. When  Peter saw how strong the wind was, he became frightened and began to  sink. Are the Pope and the Magisterium the wind for you and your General  Council?  Why are you afraid to speak the whole truth? 
You mentioned in your letter to Fr. Bourgeois that some  Maryknollers "invited" him to consider the effects of his actions on the  Society. That reminds me of the hierarchy who is more concerned about  its reputation and the clerical sexual abusers than it is about the  victims. You failed to mention how many – i.e.., 5 or 500 – actually  asked him to do this. Was a vote taken among all the MM priests and  brothers? From my sources, I have heard that many of the Maryknollers  around the world are actually in solidarity with at least a thousand lay  men and women who are supportive of Fr. Bourgeois.
Fr. Roy  Bourgeois, in his gentleness and humility, has been following Jesus to  seek justice for the poor, the vulnerable, the downtrodden, the  marginalized, those treated as un-equals in our church. We know in our  hearts that Jesus would never excommunicate Fr. Bourgeois. Jesus never  spoke of such a thing!  He has given each of us choice,  without forcing his will on us as the Vatican has done and continues to  do to show its power.
Please remember not to mix the Church with  the hierarchy. The Vatican II Council stated that we are the Church, no  longer papacy and hierarchy, but the People of God.  Church officials  ought to be speaking the words of the Scripture, and not those of the  Magisterium. History shows that Popes Paul VI, John Paul II, and  Benedict XV1 have been trying to overturn the collegial and democratic  characteristics of the Church of Vatican II. We must remember we are  united in the Church by our baptism and not by ordination.
Fr.  Dougherty, you are in a pivotal position, which gives you and the other  Maryknollers, men and women, an opportunity to set an example in favor  of justice and truth by supporting your fellow Maryknoller, Fr. Roy  Bourgeois. In so doing, you would also be giving support to the many  women who suffer injustice from the Church by  denying them their right to ordination. It seems you have two choices  to consider. 
First, you can unite Catholics, around the world by  following Jesus first, and not the hierarchy. These church officials  have pushed their authority to force you to do what they could not do!  No doubt you are familiar with the case with Sr. Joan Chittister, OSB,
  and how her community followed its conscience and told the Vatican it  couldn't follow its (the Vatican) orders. The Vatican has never gone  after the sisters as it is doing with you. I hope you do some in-depth  time with Jesus to help you.
Secondly, you can give into Rome,  forget Vatican II changes, and upset the global Catholic community, many  of whom are folks I personally know who will stop giving money to  Maryknoll. I have met many wonderful MM priests, sisters and brothers  through the years that I have attended the SOA Watch at Ft. Benning. I  saw how  Christ-like they are in their ways. By following this second way, you  place many Maryknollers in a terrible bind! You are continuing the  exclusivity in our church that the Vatican supports, i.e., women are not  equals, instead of the inclusivity practiced and taught by Jesus.
As  a staunch follower of Vatican II, I follow Jesus before any man on  earth. I give Fr. Roy Bourgeois, my brother in Christ, my complete  support in his stand for women's ordination, in particular, and for his  constant seeking for justice for the cast-asides, the ignored, the  forgotten, and the vulnerable,
 in general.
Thank you for your attention.
I would hope you will address some of the issues publicly that I have mentioned in this letter.
Sincerely in the justice and peace of Jesus,
Blanche  Crandall
Comment: Perhaps the best letter written about the tension Roy Bourgeois is causing,  Blanche is most articulate in outlining the major facts.  There is NO theological or foundational reason women cannot be ordained.  In his own writings Pope Benedict promotes following your conscience and it is the hierarchy, not the church that is promoting division and discord.  Thank you, Blanche.
Diane Dougherty
http://dianedoughertysblog.blogspot.com/